Skip to content
We do not receive endorsements from any organization listed on this website. Advertising Disclosure
Home/Featured Reviews/Benco Brokers
Featured Business Profile – 3-Time #1

Three years in a row: the Tri-State's #1 insurance agency

Personal & commercial insurance across New York, New Jersey & Connecticut.

For the third consecutive year, America’s Top Ten Best names Benco Brokers the Tri-State area’s #1 insurance agency — serving New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut.

Our evaluation committee credits the three-year streak to the same combination each time: consistent, regional customer care, a diverse lineup of elite carriers, and genuine technical innovation. It’s a rare agency that pairs the resources of a large corporate operation with the warmth and agility of a local boutique.

AWARD

#1

Tri-State insurance agency

STREAK

3 Yrs

Three years running

REGION

NY · NJ · CT

Licensed across the Tri-State

LINES

Personal & Commercial

Auto, home, liability & more

The Core Pillars of a Three-Time Champion

Why Benco keeps the top spot

Truly Personal Customer Service

No automated phone menus, no outsourced call centers, no chatbots standing between you and help. Benco prioritizes human contact — matching each client with a knowledgeable broker who learns their individual risk profile and provides real guidance and advocacy when it matters most.

Built for Everyone: Tech-Friendly Across Every Age Group

Benco calls it “accessible innovation” — a digital experience designed to suit both tech-savvy younger clients and those who prefer a simpler touch. An online dashboard lets clients file and track claims, view and print ID cards, and generate Certificates of Insurance without ever visiting a carrier’s site.

Maximizing Value

More carriers, better rates

A Robust Network of Elite Carriers

Unlike local agencies tied to just a few carriers, Benco works with significantly more. Brokers shop the entire market across that network to find the policy that actually fits each client — never a one-size-fits-all plan.

Budget-Friendly, Competitive Pricing

That carrier network creates competition that can drive premiums down. Benco stays competitively priced on the principle that strong coverage and attentive service shouldn’t demand a high cost.

Proactive Protection with Modest-Priced Annual Reviews

For a modest fee, a broker audits your existing coverage once a year — finding gaps, removing redundant expenses, and uncovering available discounts. It’s a step that can save clients thousands and prevent being underinsured during a major claim.

The Verdict from America’s Top Ten Best

A refusal to compromise

Our evaluation committee attributes Benco’s continued top ranking across the three-state region to one thing above all: a refusal to compromise. The agency combines the resources of a large corporate operation with the warmth and agility of a local boutique — and its clients feel the difference. If you’re in New York, New Jersey, or Connecticut, it’s worth requesting a quote or scheduling an annual review.

As referenced across national media

BloombergCBSMSNBCNBCUSA Today